There was that one time Trixie took Pinkie's mouth away.
This isn't that different.
This isn't that different.
But that was under the influence of Trixie's corrupted magic. I doubt Pinkie Pie could do that by herself.
The point is that it CAN be done. Ergo, it's not that hard to believe that it might have happened again.
Ok I guess that's true. I guess I didn't think of it that way.
And it's Pinkie Pie. If someone separated her mouth and eyes from her and gave them back detached, couldn't you easily see her running around juggling them?
Yeah that is true.