Discourt's avatar
XD Well offical statements can be wrong, yeah that backs up greatly but in the end we need someone in the show to make it "canon", offically saying it is a 50/50% of it being canon you need a character to call Rumble a he or she otherwise your statement as offical as it is, is uncanon.

Look at at how a staff member said Rarity would get a episode in season 3, her statement was offical but because they felt Rarity was too rude/mean they rewrote the entire episode into Spike at your service thus making her officall statement "wrong", see my point? You can say whatever but in the end the writer's and the show itself may make you a lyer as they went a different route to what you offically stated.
Mamandil's avatar
Are you being serious right now ? Or you just wanted to mess with people for fun ? Because I seriously can't tell. :iconnotsureifseriousplz:
Discourt's avatar
Well it is true. XD A staff member when writing a new scene with Rumble could have ponies call him a she or a girl thus making that "offical statement" wrong as a other staff member made Rumble being a filly canon by having ponies refer to her as one, it doesn't matter how offically you say something is because others could make it uncanon or not true.

If Rumble ever gets called a he/boy in show then fine awesome, but there's a 50% of a chance someone will write in Rumble being a filly you just can't deny that chance. Again look at the offical "Everyone of the Mane6 would get a episode" statement, what happen? No Rarity episode and it's because the writers "rewrote" her episode into another Applejack episode, so a offical statment was made wrong by the show's staff.

As of yet Rumble's canon gender is still unknown, even with that offically statement they could change him into a filly later if they want because as of yet Rumble's gender hasn't been stated "in show".

Also Faust never wanted Twi to be a Alicorn but because they left they threw out all of her ideas/statements making them uncanon.
Mamandil's avatar
I was talking about the thread altogether.
So let me get this straight :
You ask if Rumble is a filly or not, Ambassador answers you with actual facts, but somehow you don't want to believe him so you start rambling about some complete irrelevant stuff just to try and prove that we can't tell for sure if Rumble is supposed to be a colt or a filly.

To this I really gotta ask : Why the fuck did you even ask that question in the first place ? Like, seriously man, what the actual fuck ? What's the point of asking someone a question if, according to you, there is no answer to it ?

Now, let me get to your two previous messages. That example with season three's Rarity episode being canceled is a pretty bad one.
Do you really think something similar could happen for the gender of a background pony ? As of right now, it's Thunderlane's brother, but hey, who knows, they might turn him into Thunderlane's sister, because you know, they really care about background ponies' story, and a detail like this, well I mean, wow, it's like super fucking important.

"Also Faust never wanted Twi to be a Alicorn" You might wanna get your facts straight before trying to prove a point bruh. Faust did plan to turn Twi into an alicorn at some point. Probably for the last episode, but now that's irrelevant.

I also really want to underline the fact that you simply ignored what Ambassador said about the eyelashes. There was no need to add something more than that, because he's right. In MLP:FiM's design, just like children have three light reflections in the eyes, and adults have only two, females have eyelashes and males do not. End of story. So there is actually no need to hear his voice, or hear someone call him a he or a she in the show.

I'm still hoping you were just trolling, and if that case, that was a great bait. I'll give it a 9/10

If you're serious, then I am looking foward to reading your answer to this, because judging from what you said, I know you're just going to deny everything I just said, and start rambling with some random irrelvant-and-not-always-true facts, just to try and prove that you're right, and boy it's gonna be fun to read.
Discourt's avatar
I didn't say I didn't believe him. XD I was just saying offical statements can and had been wrong.