Yeah, Dumped is a pre-movie dud... and anything that scores ten or more points on the Atrocity notepages is an atrocity by MrEnter's standards, so I think that he could consider Dumped an Animated Atrocity.
I'd love to see an Animated Atrocity on The Great Snail Race. Please tell me I'm not the only person who finds that to be worse than A Pal for Gary!
...how?!
I mean, The Great Snail Race isn't a good episode... but A Pal for Gary was far worse! How do you hate The Great Snail Race more? I mean, A Pal for Gary is the most infuriating things I've seen. Not the worst thing, but the most infuriating. I mean, maybe you had higher expectations so you didn't hate it as much... I could understand that, but how aren't you infuriated by any of the things in A Pal for Gary far more than you do any other episode?
I mean, The Great Snail Race isn't a good episode... but A Pal for Gary was far worse! How do you hate The Great Snail Race more? I mean, A Pal for Gary is the most infuriating things I've seen. Not the worst thing, but the most infuriating. I mean, maybe you had higher expectations so you didn't hate it as much... I could understand that, but how aren't you infuriated by any of the things in A Pal for Gary far more than you do any other episode?
I dunno. Maybe it's because Great Snail Race came out when I was a little kid, and I had two or three pet cats, and it showed Gary graphically exploding on-screen? We've seen Spongebob act incredibly oblivious and stupid, but I can't think of any episode, before or since, that's portrayed him as being genuinely selfishly abusive. In A Pal for Gary he was well-intentioned and trying to do the right thing, which is in-character for him. In Great Snail Race, he abused his beloved pet just for the sake of one-upping his neighbor. Yeah he apologized, but it still leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
I guess I understand that... I still hate A Pal for Gary more.
I respect and understand your opinion
Thank you. I respect your opinion too, while I was a little confused by it before, you did explain your thoughts well enough that I see where you're coming from.