[x]

deviantART

 

Comment on 'Real' Music by ~Xinyun [parent]

~Rageandlove77:iconRageandlove77: May 14, 2008, 5:27:07 PM
"real music" is music that uses real instruments. no rap or hip hop crap.
"real Music" insludes:
Alternative
rock
classical
ect...

--
When I dance, I headbang. :headbang: ROCK.ON.
-------------------------------------
Death to the girl at the end of the Serenade!!!

Devious Comments

~Xinyun:iconXinyun: May 13, 2008, 8:12:43 PM
What is 'real' music, in your opinion?
I think real music is actually mozart/bach's pieces. We get absorbed in pop and rock, but it seems as not everyone has the appreciation of music without lyrics.

--
你好！~要是你可以看得懂，那就耶啦！~~

^w^
~Maxw3ll:iconMaxw3ll: May 13, 2008, 8:14:08 PM
REAL MUSIC IS MUSIC MADE OUT OF EGGS AND BACON I LIEK THAT KIND THE BEST SO ITS REAL.

--
brb.
=skulkey:iconskulkey: May 13, 2008, 8:14:40 PM
WTF?! music is music, whether it sucks or not...

--
step 1. look up Epimenides
setp 2. get it now?
~ForsakenAngel89:iconForsakenAngel89: May 13, 2008, 8:15:02 PM
"Real music" is whatever speaks tothe listener there is no "right or wrong" in music
=skulkey:iconskulkey: May 13, 2008, 8:15:27 PM
besides, Tchaikosvky owns both their asses...

--
step 1. look up Epimenides
setp 2. get it now?
`disintegration:icondisintegration: May 13, 2008, 8:29:38 PM
There is no real music because there is no such thing as false music. Music is music, period. Adjectives such as real of fake do not apply.

Maybe someone on an acid trip whose brain distorts sensorial input transforming visuals into sounds... maybe that could be classified as fake music, since music is not taking place anywhere. But other than that, the real/fake music argument is a huge pile of bullshit to me.

I'm a classical trained pianist, btw, so it's not like I'm out to defend pop music or anything like that.

--
Morbid fact of the week: Each year, the Malagasy people of Madagascar perform a funeral tradition called Famadihana. This ceremony involves digging up the bones of their loved ones, dressing them with new clothes and dancing with them.
=skulkey:iconskulkey: May 13, 2008, 8:38:26 PM
actually, it doesn't matter whether the person is on drugs or not, because the only reality we perceive is subjective. other than that, i agree with you entirely, as i indicated in my response to the OP.

--
step 1. look up Epimenides
setp 2. get it now?
~LoboSabio:iconLoboSabio: May 13, 2008, 8:39:38 PM
Music is music. It doesn't matter who's playing it. It's still music.

--
"Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better." -Samuel Beckett

Silflay hraka, u embleer rah.
`disintegration:icondisintegration: May 13, 2008, 8:45:41 PM
What I meant is that music, being an arrangement of sound and silence in time, is deliberate. Sensorial deception via drugs, however, is not (sure, you are in control of the act of taking drugs, but the effects and reactions it creates are not up to you.) Since there is no musician behind sensorial deception, I'd say one could argue such music is indeed "fake."

I agree about our perceptions being subjective. There is still, however, a degree of control your brain possesses that some drugs take away for certain lapses of time.

--
Morbid fact of the week: Each year, the Malagasy people of Madagascar perform a funeral tradition called Famadihana. This ceremony involves digging up the bones of their loved ones, dressing them with new clothes and dancing with them.
=skulkey:iconskulkey: May 13, 2008, 8:51:18 PM
and what about the music i hear in my head all the time, whether something i heard or something my brain is making up? in the complete absence of drugs, mind you. is that fake?

--
step 1. look up Epimenides
setp 2. get it now?
Previous Page12345...Next Page
Sign up to reply to this thread! <3

Site Map

©2009 deviantART. All rights reserved
About Us | Contact Us | Help & FAQ Advertise | Services Etiquette | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Copyright Policy