Comment on Neo Redux Energy Type Icons by ILKCMP

tsikuso's avatar
tsikuso
I was looking at the rock symbol and I think that it is not so easily recognized. The first thing I thought when I looked at it was a mountain. Wouldn't it be better if it was something like in this card [link] ? I think it is more obvious and more simple than this one.
ILKCMP's avatar
ILKCMP
The Rock symbol was something actually used on the show. So no, I don't think I'll be changing it.
tsikuso's avatar
tsikuso
Also I saw some problem in deciding the poison symbol in some discussion. If you are not sure for the poison symbol you have here then you should be. This is better than the other options you made. Or you can make something like this [link] or this [link] .
ILKCMP's avatar
ILKCMP
Also, as I mentioned the Rock symbol was used in-show, the Poison symbol is also something that has been used officially -- it's the symbol found on Koffing. Part of why I wanted to change the Poison symbol was because it was too "skull-like."

If any symbol is going to be changed, it would be Ground, and possibly Flying (Flying to its Battrio representation). However, as I'm so far along in the project, I doubt I would change any more symbols.
tsikuso's avatar
tsikuso
I never noticed that the poison symbol was the same as on Koffing. You are right. And it is on Weezing as well (naturally, since it is the evolution of Koffing). The Ghost symbol was also used officially?
ILKCMP's avatar
ILKCMP
Yep -- the Ghost symbol is actually the Fog Badge.