Small-Brown-Dog's avatar
Right, I'm obviously confusing myself here.
The RNAS or the RFC would be too early in my time line.
See first 5 paragraphs of:

Mr Camms Twin by Small-Brown-Dog
paws4thot's avatar
Ah right. The RAF was formed from the RFC and RNAS in April 1918. And I actually meant the Fleet Air Arm.
Small-Brown-Dog's avatar
Yeah, pretty aware of the RAF orgin :)
Sorry, being so close to RAE Farnborough which was known as the RAF prior to the formation in April 18 has the fact burnt into my brain.
As for the FAA - perhaps an alternative Swordfish attack on an aerial Bismark ?
paws4thot's avatar
You are having ideas! :) BTW the story about Kriegsmarine Flak designators being unable to track something as slow-flying as a Swordfish is true!
Small-Brown-Dog's avatar
I have not read enough on the subject to know either way to be hones but it does sort of make sense.
The John Moffet account re getting low and waiting for the OK to release the torpedo always makes my hair stand on end.
paws4thot's avatar
Well, there are British references (plural) about Swordfish making attacks and watching the Flak burst in front of them, and I've seen a German reference about designing the designator to track at a minimum airspeed of 135kt "because no aircraft that carry torpedoes can fly slower than that".
Small-Brown-Dog's avatar
Very surprised they didn't look around the world at the contemporary potential enemy torpedo aircraft. Mind you it never surprises me that for all the efficiency of the Germans, they  often had a surprising amount of very "duff gen"  or totally underestimated  strength/capability. I guess there was also a great deal of telling those that must be obeyed what they wanted to hear as well.

Thanks for the info on that by the way it and it has got my head buzzing but it would tak a while to produce an aerial Bismark!
paws4thot's avatar
No problem. I'm only sorry I don't have any on-line sources.

Also, I'm now having an idea about "aerial torpedoes" (A few German wire-guided types apart, the "guided missile" wasn't invented until the 1950s).
View all replies