EQD's comments were largely disinterested. It was sort of a laundry list; didn't like that it was an OC, didn't like that said OC was interacting with the main cast, didn't like the amnesia thing... I get most of them, to be honest, but it was overwhelmingly negative on there.
That said, a bunch of folks came through from the EQD post and got pretty into it. It's mostly just the naysayers that bothered to go back to the post page and have a whine about things, but I'm told that's kinda normal around there.